Deciphering Dog Food Labels - Part III

AAFCO Statements - Anything Special?

Sounds impressive enough, no? We dug deeper to find out how much weight these AAFCO statements really carry.

Read on, and then decide for yourself. You can also read more about AAFCO here, and the other organizations who regulate dog food.

Nutritional Adequacy Statements - "Complete and Balanced"

In this regard, there are two AAFCO statements which you may see on dog food labels. Dog food companies may choose to display one or the other of the following two statements:-

• "(Product Name) is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food nutrient profiles for (specific life stage)."

  Before a dog food label can display this AAFCO statement, the dog food manufacturers have to ensure the product meets AAFCO’s minimum nutritional adequacy profile. They do this by using the "Calculations Method".

• "Animal feeding tests using AAFCO procedures substantiate that (name of product) provides complete and balanced nutrition for (specific life stage)."

  In this case, the product needs to pass a dog feeding trial.

Let's now take a closer look at these two methods.

Calculations Method

Calculations estimate the amount of nutrients either by an average nutrient content of ingredients, or by results of laboratory tests using standard chemical analysis.

Dog Feeding Trials

If it meets the profile, you will find the following AAFCO statement on the dog food label:

Photo by Basykes

The labels on many commercial dog food brands will proclaim to contain a nutritionally adequate dog food diet, by passing "stringent testing as required by AAFCO."

However! ... Read on ...

• A minimum of only eight dogs are required for the tests.
• The tests run for a six month period.
• During the duration of the test, 25% of the animals can be removed for varying reasons, and
• It is permissible for the remaining dogs to lose up to 15% of their starting body weight.

Now, based on the above, what conclusions can we draw as to the "stringency"(?!!) of this testing, and the value of this AAFCO statement?

Considering only six to eight dogs ate these particular dog food ingredients for six months and survived with no more than an "acceptable" 15% loss of body weight!?

We wonder how many dog owners would consider it "acceptable" for their 30 lb pooch to lose 4.5 lbs in six months?

Life Stage(s) Statement

Two profiles are used. Below is a definition of each and additional information about other profiles:

Growth/Lactation - A product intended for growing puppies, for pregnant dogs or lactating females.

Maintenance - Suitable for any adult, non-reproducing dog of normal activity level, but may not be sufficient for a growing, reproducing, or hard working dog.

Terms such as Senior or Formulated for Large Breed Adults, means the dog food ingredients meet the requirements for the maintenance profile, but nothing above that.

A product that doesn't fit within the two profiles above must state, "This product is intended for intermittent or supplemental feeding," unless it is clearly identified as a snack or treat.

Always do your own informed dog food analysis based upon the list of ingredients, and not on any vague AAFCO statements.

Dog Feeding Guidelines

Net Quantity

If you're making a dog food comparison on a cost per ounce or per pound basis, remember to always take into account the difference in moisture percentage.

Manufacturer's Name and Address

If the label states “manufactured for ...” or “distributed by...,” the dog food was actually manufactured for the dog food company by an outside manufacturer.

Although telephone numbers are not a requirement, it's a good sign of a responsible manufacturer who is open to consumer enquiries.

BACK FROM Dog Food Labels III TO Labels Introduction

BACK to Dog Food Scoop Home