Unbiased Dog Food Comparison Chart

Compare Dog Food Ratings
At a Glance




The dog food comparison chart below, provides overall dog food ratings for a wide selection of commercial dog food brands.

Dog Photo © Jenny Rollo
Checklist Photo by Kikashi
Best dog food ratings

Trust us, this was no easy feat to pull together!



Making a quality dog food comparison and trying to isolate the super premium dog food brands is quite an overwhelming exercise. The range of commercial dog foods on the market, along with their various exclusive dog food recipes and formulas ... is quite staggering!

Even celebrities seem to be jumping on the dog food bandwagon, such as:

But are they really endorsing the healthiest dog food products or not?

We encourage you to always do your research. Do a thorough dog food comparison, and don't be swayed by impressive sounding dog food ingredients on flashy labels.

We've tried to make it easy for you. You'll find important articles on our Tips for choosing top dog foods page, such as:



Dog Food Ratings

Discount Dog Supplies
Dog Food Scoop
Sniffs out Special Offers on Dog Food

See here for:

Online Pet Supplies
*FREE SHIPPING* of Dog Food

Discount Dog Supplies and Dog Food Coupons

Please note, the dog food ratings provided on our dog food comparison chart are based upon our extensive research, combined with our own personal and unbiased opinion of the quality of the various dog food brands.

We took many factors into account, including each dog food company's philosophy, and their overall commitment to sourcing the best quality dog food ingredients. Naturally, individual products' nutritional values will vary within each brand.

For now, our dog food comparison chart highlights dog food brands with a high protein dog food, a certified organic dog food, and those brands that offer a vegetarian dog food -- for the many consumers now looking for supplements to their recipes for homemade dog foods.

As Dog Food Scoop grows, we will continue to compare the best dog food brands in greater detail, along with in-depth dog food reviews.

So! Ready to find out if you're barking up the wrong tree? We hope you find our comprehensive dog food comparison chart helpful, and you're now able to compare dog foods at a glance!

DOG FOOD COMPARISON CHART

(Alphabetical Order)

DOG FOOD BRANDS

NATURAL

ORGANIC

DOG FOOD

HIGH PROTEIN DOG FOOD

VEGETARIAN

DOG FOOD

RED FLAG

INGREDIENTS

DOG FOOD

RATINGS

(0 - 5 Scoops)

Abady       By-products, Menadione (Vitamin K3)
Acana  

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

   

Active Care, Breeders Choice

       
Addiction  

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

   
Alpo       By-products,

BHA

Artificial preservatives

APD (Advanced Pet Diets) Breeders Choice        
Artemis        
Authority        
Avoderm,  Breeders Choice     Vegetarian Dog Food  
Azmira       Menadione (Vitamin K3)
Back to Basics        
Beneful      

By-products,

Artificial Coloring

Bil Jac      

By-products,

Artificial Coloring

BLUE        
BLUE Organics Organic Dog Food, OTCO Certified      
Blue Seal       By-products
BLUE Wilderness  

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

   
Burns      
By Nature Organic Dog Food, OTCO Certified

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

(Canned Only)

California Natural Organic Dog Food, OCIA Certified June 2010
Sold to P&G
Canidae

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Canine Caviar

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

CaniSource        
Cesar By-products
Chicken Soup for the Dog Lover's Soul
Diamond

By-products

Doctors Foster and Smith Menadione (Vitamin K3)
Dogswell

Dog Whisperer, Cesar Millan

Organic Dog Food, OCIA Certified

Eagle Pack Organic Quinoia
Eukanuba By-products
Evangers Organic Canned Dog Food

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Vegetarian Dog Food

June, 2009

FDA Permit Suspension

EVO

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

June 2010
Sold to P&G
Exclusive
First Mate

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Flint River Ranch
Fromm

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

GO Natural

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Goodlife Recipe By-products
Halo Spot's Stew - Ellen DeGeneres

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Harmony Farms      
Harvest Blend
Haven Naturals
HealthWise June 2010
Sold to P&G
Hills Science Diet By-products
Holistic Blend 100% Organic Canned Dog Food Grain Free High Protein Dog Food Canned Vegetarian Dog Food
Honest Kitchen Some Organic Non-Meat Ingredients Grain Free Dog Food Vegetarian Pre-Mix for Homemade  
Horizon Complete Menadione (Vitamin K3)
Horizon Legacy

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Iams By-products
Innova June 2010
Sold to P&G
Instinct, Nature's Variety

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Karma

Organic Dog Food, OneCert. Certified

June 2010
Sold to P&G
Kasco By-products
Kibbles 'n Bits By-products,

BHA

Kirkland
Merrick

Organic Chicken

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Mulligan Stew

Natural Balance, Dick Van Patten

Organic Dog Food, OTCO Certified

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Vegetarian Dog Food
Natural Defense        
Natural Planet Organics

Organic Dog Food, OTCO Certified

Natural ULTRAMIX   Menadione (Vitamin K3)
Nature's Logic   High Protein Dog Food
Nature's Recipe     By-products, Menadione (Vitamin K3)
Newmans Own Organics Organic Dog Food, USDA Certified

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Menadione (Vitamin K3)
NOW

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Nutro Dog Food:
Natural Choice, Max, Ultra
Menadione (Vitamin K3)
Ol' Roy

By-products,

BHA,

Artificial preservatives

ORGANIX, Castor and Pollux

Organic Dog Food, OCIA Certified

Orijen  

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Party Animal

Organic Canned Dog Food, OCIA Certified

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Pedigree

By-products,

Artificial preservatives

PetGuard Organics Organic Dog Food, USDA Certified Vegetarian Dog Food  
Pet Promise Menadione (Vitamin K3)
Pinnacle Organic Quinoia

Grain Free

 High Protein Dog Food

Prairie, Nature's Variety

Precise
Professional
Purina Pro Plan By-products,

Artificial preservatives

Purina One

By-products,

Artificial preservatives

Rachel Ray Nutrish Menadione (Vitamin K3)
Royal Canin Vegetarian Dog Food  
Solid Gold

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Summit Holistics - Petcurean

Summit Originals - Petcurean

Taste of the Wild

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Timberwolf

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Tuffy's       By-products, BHA, Menadione (Vitamin K3)
Vets Choice Holistic Health Extension Organic Chicken    
Wellness

Grain Free

  High Protein Dog Food

Wenaewe Organic Dog Food USDA, OTA, OIA, IBD, IFOAM Certifications

Organic Vegetarian Dog Food
Weruva (Canned dog food only)
Wysong Vegetarian Dog Food
ZiwiPeak


FROM Dog Food Comparison Chart TO Dog Food Scoop Home

Page copy protected against web site content infringement by Copyscape