Unbiased Dog Food Comparison Chart
Compare Dog Food Ratings
At a Glance
The dog food comparison chart below, provides overall dog food ratings for a wide selection of commercial dog food brands.
 |
Trust us, this was no easy feat to pull together!
Making a quality dog food comparison and trying to isolate the super premium dog food brands is quite an overwhelming exercise. The range of commercial dog foods on the market, along with their various exclusive dog food recipes and formulas ... is quite staggering!
Even celebrities seem to be jumping on the dog food bandwagon, such as:
- Newmans's Own Organics dog food by the late Paul Newman
- Nutrish, Rachel Ray dog food
- Halo pet food by Ellen Degeneres
- Dick Van Patten's Natural Balance dog food.
But are they really endorsing the healthiest dog food products or not?
We encourage you to always do your research. Do a thorough dog food comparison, and don't be swayed by impressive sounding dog food ingredients on flashy labels.
We've tried to make it easy for you. You'll find important articles on our Tips for choosing top dog foods page, such as:
- Choosing the best commercial dog food -- What to seek/what to avoid,
- How to select the healthiest dog food for your own unique pooch, and
- How to decipher dog food ingredients labels -- See how cryptic and misleading they are.
Dog Food Ratings
Please note, the dog food ratings provided on our dog food comparison chart are based upon our extensive research, combined with our own personal and unbiased opinion of the quality of the various dog food brands.
We took many factors into account, including each dog food company's philosophy, and their overall commitment to sourcing the best quality dog food ingredients. Naturally, individual products' nutritional values will vary within each brand.
For now, our dog food comparison chart highlights dog food brands with a high protein dog food, a certified organic dog food, and those brands that offer a vegetarian dog food -- for the many consumers now looking for supplements to their recipes for homemade dog foods.
As Dog Food Scoop grows, we will continue to compare the best dog food brands in greater detail, along with in-depth dog food reviews.
So! Ready to find out if you're barking up the wrong tree? We hope you find our comprehensive dog food comparison chart helpful, and you're now able to compare dog foods at a glance!
 |
|
Sniffs out Special Offers on Dog Food |
|
See here for: Online
Pet Supplies |
DOG FOOD COMPARISON CHART | |||||
| DOG FOOD BRANDS | NATURAL ORGANIC DOG FOODS | HIGH PROTEIN DOG FOOD | VEGETARIAN DOG FOOD | RED FLAG INGREDIENTS | DOG FOOD RATINGS (0 - 5 Scoops) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abady | By-products, Menadione (Vitamin K3) |  |
|||
| Acana | Grain Free
High Protein Dog Food |
 |
|||
| Active Care, Breeders Choice |  |
||||
| Addiction | Grain Free
High Protein Dog Food |
|
|||
| Alpo | By-products, BHA Artificial preservatives | |
|||
| APD (Advanced Pet Diets) Breeders Choice | |
||||
| Artemis | |
||||
| Authority |  |
||||
| Avoderm, Breeders Choice | Vegetarian Dog Food | |
|||
| Azmira | Menadione (Vitamin K3) |  |
|||
| Back to Basics | |
||||
| Beneful | By-products, Artificial Coloring | |
|||
| Bil Jac | By-products, Artificial Coloring | |
|||
| BLUE | |
||||
| BLUE Organics | Organic Dog Food, OTCO Certified | |
|||
| Blue Seal | By-products | |
|||
| BLUE Wilderness | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Burns | |
||||
| By Nature | Organic Dog Food, OTCO Certified | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food (Canned Only) | |
||
| California Natural | Organic Dog Food, OCIA Certified | June 2010
Sold to P&G |
 |
||
| Canidae | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Canine Caviar | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| CaniSource | |
||||
| Cesar | By-products | |
|||
| Chicken Soup for the Dog Lover's Soul | |
||||
| Diamond | By-products | |
|||
| Doctors Foster and Smith | Menadione (Vitamin K3) | |
|||
| Dogswell | |
||||
| Dog Whisperer, Cesar Millan | Organic Dog Food, OCIA Certified | |
|||
| Eagle Pack | Organic Quinoia | |
|||
| Eukanuba | By-products | |
|||
| Evangers | Organic Canned Dog Food | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | Vegetarian Dog Food | June, 2009 FDA Permit Suspension |
|
| EVO | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | June 2010
Sold to P&G |
|
||
| Exclusive | |
||||
| First Mate | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Flint River Ranch | |
||||
| Fromm | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| GO Natural | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Goodlife Recipe | By-products | |
|||
| Halo Spot's Stew - Ellen DeGeneres | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Harmony Farms | |
||||
| Harvest Blend | |
||||
| Haven Naturals | |
||||
| HealthWise | June 2010
Sold to P&G |
|
|||
| Hills Science Diet | By-products | |
|||
| Holistic Blend | 100% Organic Canned Dog Food | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | Canned Vegetarian Dog Food | |
|
| Honest Kitchen | Some Organic Non-Meat Ingredients | Grain Free Dog Food | Vegetarian Pre-Mix for Homemade | |
|
| Horizon Complete | Menadione (Vitamin K3) | |
|||
| Horizon Legacy | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Iams | By-products | |
|||
| Innova | June 2010
Sold to P&G |
|
|||
| Instinct, Nature's Variety | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Karma | Organic Dog Food, OneCert. Certified | June 2010
Sold to P&G |
|
||
| Kasco | By-products | |
|||
| Kibbles 'n Bits | By-products, BHA | |
|||
| Kirkland | |
||||
| Merrick | Organic Chicken | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
||
| Mulligan Stew | |
||||
| Natural Balance, Dick Van Patten | Organic Dog Food, OTCO Certified | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | Vegetarian Dog Food | |
|
| Natural Defense | |
||||
| Natural Planet Organics | Organic Dog Food, OTCO Certified | |
|||
| Natural ULTRAMIX | Menadione (Vitamin K3) | |
|||
| Nature's Logic | High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Nature's Recipe | By-products, Menadione (Vitamin K3) | |
|||
| Newmans Own Organics | Organic Dog Food, USDA Certified | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | Menadione (Vitamin K3) | |
|
| NOW | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Nutro Dog Food: Natural Choice, Max, Ultra | Menadione (Vitamin K3) | |
|||
| Ol' Roy | By-products, BHA, Artificial preservatives | |
|||
| ORGANIX, Castor and Pollux | Organic Dog Food, OCIA Certified | |
|||
| Orijen | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Party Animal | Organic Canned Dog Food, OCIA Certified | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
||
| Pedigree | By-products, Artificial preservatives | |
|||
| PetGuard Organics | Organic Dog Food, USDA Certified | Vegetarian Dog Food | |
||
| Pet Promise | Menadione (Vitamin K3) | |
|||
| Pinnacle | Organic Quinoia | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
||
| Prairie, Nature's Variety | |
||||
| Precise | |
||||
| Professional | |
||||
| Purina Pro Plan | By-products, Artificial preservatives | |
|||
| Purina One | By-products, Artificial preservatives | |
|||
| Rachel Ray Nutrish | Menadione (Vitamin K3) | |
|||
| Royal Canin | Vegetarian Dog Food | |
|||
| Solid Gold | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Summit Holistics - Petcurean | |
||||
| Summit Originals - Petcurean | |
||||
| Taste of the Wild | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Timberwolf | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Tuffy's | By-products, BHA, Menadione (Vitamin K3) | |
|||
| Vets Choice Holistic Health Extension | Organic Chicken | |
|||
| Wellness | Grain Free High Protein Dog Food | |
|||
| Wenaewe | Organic Dog Food USDA, OTA, OIA, IBD, IFOAM Certifications | Organic Vegetarian Dog Food | |
||
| Weruva (Canned dog food only) | |
||||
| Wysong | Vegetarian Dog Food | |
|||
| ZiwiPeak | |
||||
You are here: Home > Dog Food Comparison Chart
Follow Our Updates!
Reviews by Ranking
Reviews by Type
Reviews by Brand
Shopping
Important Tips
Dog Health Problems
Articles
Scoopings